Reclaiming a Continent: Navigating the Respectful Reference to Turtle Island
In an era increasingly attuned to decolonization and Indigenous sovereignty, the term "Turtle Island" is gaining prominence, moving from the sacred narratives of First Nations to mainstream discourse. Far more than a mere alternative name for North America, "Turtle Island" carries profound spiritual, cultural, and historical significance, representing a worldview antithetical to colonial constructs. For non-Indigenous people, understanding how to refer to Turtle Island respectfully is not just about using the right words; it’s about acknowledging a rich tapestry of Indigenous knowledge, challenging settler-colonial narratives, and fostering genuine reconciliation.
The journey to respectful reference begins with understanding the term’s origins. "Turtle Island" stems from creation stories prevalent across numerous Indigenous nations, including the Haudenosaunee (Iroquois Confederacy), Anishinaabe (Ojibwe, Odawa, Potawatomi), and Lenape (Delaware) peoples, among many others. While the specifics vary from nation to nation, a common thread involves a great flood and a courageous animal, often a muskrat or beaver, diving deep to retrieve earth, which is then placed on the back of a giant turtle. This turtle grows to become the landmass we now know as North America.
For Indigenous peoples, this is not just a myth; it is a foundational narrative that defines their relationship with the land. It speaks to a deep spiritual connection, a sense of belonging, and a cosmology that positions humans as integral, rather than dominant, within the natural world. As Robin Wall Kimmerer, a Citizen Potawatomi botanist and author, beautifully articulates in "Braiding Sweetgrass," the land is not merely a resource but a living entity, a generous provider, and a relative. "Turtle Island" embodies this reverence, a stark contrast to the utilitarian perspective often associated with colonial naming conventions.
"Turtle Island" vs. "North America": A Decolonial Lens
The use of "Turtle Island" is an act of reclamation and decolonization. The name "North America" is a colonial imposition, derived from Amerigo Vespucci, a European explorer. It represents a history of conquest, territorial appropriation, and the systematic erasure of Indigenous presence and sovereignty. This nomenclature reflects a Eurocentric worldview that categorized and claimed lands already inhabited for millennia.
Conversely, "Turtle Island" predates European contact by thousands of years. It represents Indigenous continuity, resilience, and an enduring connection to ancestral territories. When Indigenous peoples use "Turtle Island," they are asserting their identity, their history, and their inherent rights to the land. They are reminding the world that these lands were, and continue to be, home to diverse nations with distinct cultures, languages, and governance systems.
For non-Indigenous individuals and institutions, recognizing this distinction is crucial. Simply swapping "North America" for "Turtle Island" without understanding its profound implications risks reducing it to a trendy buzzword, stripping it of its power and meaning. The respectful use of the term necessitates an awareness of the historical injustices perpetrated under colonial names and a commitment to uplifting Indigenous perspectives.
Navigating Respectful Use: Considerations for Non-Indigenous People
The growing adoption of "Turtle Island" in land acknowledgements, educational materials, and public discourse by non-Indigenous allies is generally a positive development, signaling a desire for more inclusive and accurate language. However, this adoption must be undertaken with care, thoughtfulness, and an unwavering commitment to Indigenous self-determination.
-
Context is Paramount: The most appropriate contexts for non-Indigenous people to use "Turtle Island" are generally when discussing Indigenous issues, history, or land. It is particularly impactful in land acknowledgements, where it serves as a powerful reminder of the pre-colonial Indigenous presence and ongoing sovereignty. For example, beginning an event by stating, "We acknowledge that we are gathering on the traditional, ancestral, and unceded territories of the , on Turtle Island," grounds the acknowledgement in a broader Indigenous cosmology.
-
Avoid Appropriation and Tokenism: "Turtle Island" is not a casual substitute for "North America" in all contexts. It is not meant to be used flippantly or as a generic, feel-good term without genuine understanding. Using it merely to appear "woke" or to co-opt Indigenous identity is disrespectful and performative. Non-Indigenous individuals should avoid using it in contexts where it feels like an attempt to erase their own settler identity or to speak on behalf of Indigenous peoples. The intention should always be to amplify Indigenous voices, not to overshadow them.
-
Prioritize Specificity: While "Turtle Island" is a powerful overarching term, it is a broad concept. When possible and appropriate, always strive to name the specific Indigenous nations whose traditional territories you are on. For instance, instead of just saying "Turtle Island," specify "the traditional territories of the Anishinaabeg, Haudenosaunee, Lenape, and Huron-Wendat peoples, located on Turtle Island." This demonstrates a deeper understanding and respect for the diverse Indigenous nations and their distinct connections to specific geographies. It also prevents the homogenization of Indigenous identities.
-
Listen and Learn: The most respectful approach is to listen to how Indigenous communities refer to their own lands and to follow their lead. Different nations may have different preferences or specific terms for their territories. Engage with Indigenous-led organizations, educational resources, and community members to deepen your understanding. This is an ongoing process of learning, unlearning, and re-education.
-
Understand the "Why": Before using the term, ask yourself why you are using it. Is it to challenge colonial narratives? To acknowledge Indigenous sovereignty? To connect with a deeper understanding of the land? If the answer is genuinely rooted in respect, education, and decolonization, then its use is likely appropriate. If it’s for convenience, trendiness, or to avoid deeper engagement, reconsider.
The Power of Language in Decolonization
Language is not merely a tool for communication; it is a carrier of culture, history, and worldview. The deliberate choice to use "Turtle Island" is a recognition of this power. It is a conscious effort to dismantle the linguistic remnants of colonialism and to make space for Indigenous perspectives to thrive. By embracing "Turtle Island," non-Indigenous people participate in a subtle yet significant act of decolonization, challenging the mental maps imposed by colonial powers and inviting a deeper, more reciprocal relationship with the land and its original caretakers.
As Ta-Nehisi Coates eloquently states in "Between the World and Me," "The Dreamers will always tell you it is in the past. They will say it was a long time ago, they will say the system was not meant to be cruel. But you were born into a world designed to be cruel to you." While Coates speaks of racial injustice, his words resonate with the enduring impact of colonialism. The names we use for places are not neutral; they are imbued with history, power, and ideology. Choosing "Turtle Island" is a conscious step towards acknowledging a different, more just history and imagining a future built on respect and equity.
Conclusion: An Ongoing Journey of Respect and Reciprocity
Referring to Turtle Island respectfully is an ongoing journey, not a destination. It requires continuous education, self-reflection, and a willingness to adapt one’s language and understanding. It means moving beyond token gestures to genuinely engage with the principles of decolonization and Indigenous sovereignty.
For non-Indigenous people, it is an invitation to acknowledge the enduring presence and wisdom of Indigenous peoples, to challenge the historical amnesia of colonialism, and to embrace a more accurate and respectful understanding of the lands we inhabit. By understanding the deep cultural and spiritual significance of "Turtle Island," by using it thoughtfully and contextually, and by always centering Indigenous voices, we can contribute to a more just and equitable future—one where the original names and narratives of this continent are honored and celebrated. The land remembers its true name, and it is time we all did too.
